Mastodon
· A new essay every Monday Sign in Join the Commons
Dr Robert N. Winter For Critical Thinkers
Topic

Artificial Intelligence

On artificial intelligence—not as novelty, but as the old failures of leadership and judgement conducted at unprecedented speed and expense.

36 essays · 3 conversations
EssayMonday 28 September 2026

The Agent That Cannot Answer

An agent, in law and in the older political vocabulary, is someone who exercises judgement on another's behalf and answers for having exercised it. The systems we have agreed to call agents can do the first and not the second, and the evidence on what that costs has started to arrive.

The Commons 11 min read
EssayMonday 31 August 2026

Raising the Sea Level

The remedy has no dashboard, vests over years, and mostly benefits your successor—which is precisely why it is avoided. The final essay in the Prior Obligations series sets out what raising the general level of competence actually requires, and why no tool can be bought in its place.

Inner Circle 5 min read
EssayMonday 24 August 2026

One Rule for the Deck, Another for the Bridge

The mandate travels downward and the exemption stays where it was written. The fourth essay in the Prior Obligations series examines organisations that require AI of the crew while the bridge quietly abstains, the consumption quota that enforces it, and the questions a director might ask.

The Commons 6 min read
EssayMonday 17 August 2026

The Verification Asymmetry

I can audit a model's output on leadership and must take its tax advice on faith. That asymmetry is the whole problem, and it is not psychological. The third essay in the Prior Obligations series argues that AI does not deskill the competent—it unmasks the fake.

The Commons 5 min read
ConversationWednesday 12 August 2026

You Cannot Skip the Stages

My guest this week is Jay Fontanini, founder of the AI Executive Accelerator, who spent three decades in property and casualty insurance before turning to building software and teaching executives to think with it rather than perform having thought.

EssayMonday 10 August 2026

The Score

A score creates an owner, a dashboard, a target, and a budget—everything except an improvement in the condition it measures. The second essay in the Prior Obligations series examines what happens when 'psychological debt' becomes a number, and which way its arrows actually run.

The Commons 5 min read
EssayMonday 3 August 2026

The Old Complaint in New Clothes

Six new names for old wounds. The 'psychological debt' said to accompany AI is neither novel nor peculiar to the technology—it is the perennial business of managing people through change. The first of five essays on what the diagnosis gets right, and what it conveniently overlooks.

Free to read 6 min read
EssayMonday 29 June 2026

The Trouble Was Never the IdeaOpinion

Generative AI has made plausible ideas nearly free, and a fashionable argument says this changes everything. It doesn't. Ideas were never scarce—judgement was, and remains so. On Grub Street at industrial scale, AI slop, and the only mile that was ever hard.

Free to read 5 min read
EssayMonday 25 May 2026

The Permanent Pilot

Part II of a IV part series: twenty-five per cent of organisations have moved AI experiments into production after nine years of trying. Fifty-four per cent expect to within three to six months—a prediction that has appeared in every major survey for nearly a decade.

The Commons 7 min read
Now playing
—
0:00